Leo Schumann

ONE WORD CHANGES THE QUESTION

How Can I do this?

A verdict. It can be answered with a no.

PROCESS

Drag the slider and watch where the paths go. Illustrative.

The quiet questions

At critical moments, we ask ourselves quiet questions. The answers decide whether we lean in or pull back.

They surface in evaluative situations, after critical feedback, when we compare ourselves to others, under high stress, when the work takes high effort, and during transitions. Pulling back is an understandable response. But the distance between struggling and giving up is often shorter, and more changeable, than it looks. That space between struggle and surrender is where this work happens.

Nearly four in ten students who start college have no credential six years later. National Student Clearinghouse Research Center, 2025.

1 · A common moment

2 · The quiet question

A process question. It skips past whether, and goes straight to how.

3 · Where each question tends to lead

THE MOMENT THE SPACE BETWEEN STRUGGLE AND SURRENDER WEEK 1WEEK 15 ENGAGEMENT

DOES NEXT

goes to office hours

WHICH LEADS TO

a better second exam

AND SEEMS TO CONFIRM

"There is a way, and I’m finding it"

Illustrative, not data.

Change the question, and you change the answers it allows.

Prove: a verdict

"Can I do it?" asks for a diagnosis. "No" is an allowed answer, so every struggle starts to look like evidence, and stepping back starts to feel reasonable.

Improve: a process

"HOW can I do it?" adds one word and removes one answer. It no longer entertains the possibility that I can't. It assumes a way exists and sends the mind straight to looking for it.

Why it compounds

Small answers become spirals

How we explain a moment shapes what we do next. What we do shapes what happens. What happens seems to confirm the explanation, and the next moment starts from there.

Follow one student after a first low exam, three turns in each direction. Wise interventions aim at the first turn.

TURN 1 OF 3 · ATTRIBUTION

“This exam shows me what to change.”

Illustrative. Draws on Gregory Walton's account of self-reinforcing spirals in Ordinary Magic.

ATTRIBUTION
BEHAVIOR
OUTCOME
CONFIRMATION
ATTRIBUTION Starts with: “HOW can I do this?” Each turn starts a little higher

Intervention Finder

Which quiet question are your students asking?

Choose what you are seeing, when you can reach students and how, and the Finder returns research-based approaches with the evidence behind each.

Open the Intervention Finder →

For institutions

What is action research?

How a university can keep learning which moments matter, and what helps students through them.

See how it works →

About Leo

Partnerships, keynotes and research

Social psychologist, speaker and advisor to colleges and universities.

Work with Leo →