Leo Schumann

Action research · Case study

Rewriting the probation letter

Colleges send an academic probation letter every term. It is meant to help students recover. When we asked students what they heard in it, many described shame. This is how that letter was rewritten with students, and how the learning carried on past the letter into policy and practice.

01Plan

Find the moment, and listen to the students in it

More than one in eight college students will be placed on academic probation at some point. The notification is a routine administrative step, and most institutions write it to do three things: state the student's status, spell out the consequences, and point to support.

Before changing anything, we read the letters institutions were actually sending and asked students who had received them what they took away. The facts came through. So did a second message nobody intended. Students described feeling ashamed, singled out and unsure they belonged in college. Shame tends to make people withdraw, which is the opposite of what a student on probation needs to do. Many put off seeing an advisor until things were worse.

That gave the cycle a clear target: keep every fact and requirement in the letter, and change what it implied about the student.

02Act

Revise the letter with students, not just for them

The revised letter went through rounds of student feedback. It kept the same policy, deadlines and consequences, and changed four things:

  1. Probation as a process, not a label. It describes a period for learning and getting back on track, with a defined end.
  2. You are not the only one. It says plainly that many students go through probation and return to good standing.
  3. Real reasons students struggle. It names personal, financial, health and family circumstances, not only effort or ability.
  4. A clear way back. It lays out the requirements, names specific people to talk to, and expresses confidence that the student can meet the standard.

Some versions also included short accounts from students who had been on probation, describing what helped them.

From a sample revised letter

"The probation process is designed to be helpful for you and to promote a successful experience at the university."

"You should also know that you are not alone in experiencing difficulties. Many students participate in the academic probation process each year and, by accessing campus resources and reaching out to others for support, many leave the process and continue on to have a successful career."

03Observe

Test it the way you would test any intervention

Students placed on probation were randomly assigned to receive either the standard letter or the revised one, and then followed over time. Those who received the psychologically attuned letter reported less shame and stigma, and were more willing to reach out for support. The full results are being prepared for publication, so I describe them here only in general terms.

A letter that works in one place is a starting point for the next campus, not a template to copy.

04Reflect

Carry the learning into policy and practice

What carried over was the method, more than the wording. Each time the work moved to a new institution, it started again with that institution's own letter and its own students.

The letter also turned out to be one part of a larger process. Once people saw how students were reading it, the questions widened: how advisors follow up, how standing is communicated, and what the probation policy itself asks of students. Over later cycles, institutions changed those practices and policies, to the point where a special letter intervention was no longer needed. That is the aim of action research: the fix becomes how the place works.

For your institution

Three questions to ask about your own letter

The Intervention Finder lists related research on institutional messages.

This work was led by Shannon Brady with Gregory Walton, Geoffrey Cohen and colleagues, including me, through the College Transition Collaborative. The quotations above are from a sample revised letter prepared for that work.

Want to look at your institution's letters together?

Start a conversation